The incredible/self manipulating Michael Moore
Not everyone has heard of Michael Moore, neither did I until I watched this film in my english 102 class. Don't be confused by the title though I really did enjoy his film but at the same time it sure made me have mixed feelings about it, allow me to explain why.
Allow me to explain why I considered Michael Moore incredible; I enjoyed and found it slightly humorous that he compared america's ways to the Romes ways decades ago. Which ironically he did manage to find several similarities to them, but why did he only compare the bad judgmental side of America ? Is it forbidden to speak about America's great features ? Or are we just going to pretend they don't exist at all.

Besides that factor, Michael Moore definitely used the rhetorical triangle method in his movie in several different ways, but the one that did particularly catch my attention the most was when he went to interview the families that had lost their loved ones and how the loved ones were now used to make money off of companies they were referred to as dead peasants. This type of persuasion was pathos, it was given to the audience so they can feel sad and emotional towards the topic. But Michael also used logos because he had his own research done in order to support his point of view, therefore making it almost impossible to disagree with him.

Although one thing I admired from his film was how he managed to really make you think deeply about america itself. He provided us examples with a cat video saying if america would be remembered for their stupid odd videos posted on the internet.

Or would we be known for kicking people out of their house by the police department and the sheriff. But if you pay close attention there is always a reason as to why a foreclosure occurs; but Michael moore did not include that in his film. He only showed a video of a family recording themselves when the sheriff had to come forcefully inside the premises by taking down the doors as the family gathered around each other stating their names. As persuasive as that may seem when it comes to my emotional appeal for feeling sorry for the family having to be kicked out of their home, it still doesn't state the true facts as to why it happened. If Michael Moore wanted to catch his audience's true opinion on the subject he could have shown the reason why the family was being kicked out, that way he could have had stronger evidence.

So regardless of Michael Moore's pro's of filming this film "Capitalism" the cons are weighing heavily upon him as well. He provided good information, but only information that he knew would have an effect towards us so we could agree with him. Just like any other media out there, Michael followed similarly in the same path of manipulation. He showed us the issues of capitalism but only through his eyes and what he believed, he left information out as an advantage to get his audience attention to the fullest.

Besides that factor, Michael Moore definitely used the rhetorical triangle method in his movie in several different ways, but the one that did particularly catch my attention the most was when he went to interview the families that had lost their loved ones and how the loved ones were now used to make money off of companies they were referred to as dead peasants. This type of persuasion was pathos, it was given to the audience so they can feel sad and emotional towards the topic. But Michael also used logos because he had his own research done in order to support his point of view, therefore making it almost impossible to disagree with him.

Although one thing I admired from his film was how he managed to really make you think deeply about america itself. He provided us examples with a cat video saying if america would be remembered for their stupid odd videos posted on the internet.

Or would we be known for kicking people out of their house by the police department and the sheriff. But if you pay close attention there is always a reason as to why a foreclosure occurs; but Michael moore did not include that in his film. He only showed a video of a family recording themselves when the sheriff had to come forcefully inside the premises by taking down the doors as the family gathered around each other stating their names. As persuasive as that may seem when it comes to my emotional appeal for feeling sorry for the family having to be kicked out of their home, it still doesn't state the true facts as to why it happened. If Michael Moore wanted to catch his audience's true opinion on the subject he could have shown the reason why the family was being kicked out, that way he could have had stronger evidence.

So regardless of Michael Moore's pro's of filming this film "Capitalism" the cons are weighing heavily upon him as well. He provided good information, but only information that he knew would have an effect towards us so we could agree with him. Just like any other media out there, Michael followed similarly in the same path of manipulation. He showed us the issues of capitalism but only through his eyes and what he believed, he left information out as an advantage to get his audience attention to the fullest.


Your entry makes more sense and is an eye catcher more then the movie was. He really did not state why anything happens but he runs with it.
ReplyDeletePatricia--Nice job with your new entries. You have good ideas and points. You have pretty good development and analysis. Keep digging. Good visual engagement as well.
ReplyDelete